About us
Pledge of Performance
Contact Us



Leo Fenster has been a trusted name in insurance for over 65 years. With A+ rated companies and low premiums for all lines of insurance, we are the right brokerage for you.

Established in 1938, we are a 4th generation family-run insurance brokerage. Our writing capacity includes all of New York State and New Jersey.

We strive to offer our clients the best service and attention possible, far beyond
the scope of the average broker.  Whether you came to us by recommendation, off the street or from the internet, you will receive the same excellence and knowledge that made our reputation great.

See our Trusted Choice® Pledge of Performance.

In the 1930's, Bernard Fenster, an importer-exporter from Europe, decided it was time for a new career. He found his calling in real estate. Benny, as he was affectionately known, with his son Leo, founded Fenster & Company Real Estate in 1938. With real estate sales comes the need for property insurance. Leo took the initiative to sell insurance in-house direct to his real estate clientele instead of feeding the insurance out to other agents. Leo Fenster soon became a household name in the Midwood section of Brooklyn.

Bernard Fenster passed away in 1954.

In 1959, Leo moved both companies, Fenster & Company Real Estate and Leo Fenster Insurance, from its' home of 21 years at 421 Avenue M to its' current location at 1503 Avenue J.

Leo's sons, Robert & Michael Fenster, joined the staff in the early 1970's.

The business became a 4-generation family business when Marc Fenster, Robert's son, signed on in 1996.

2004 saw the first reorganization of the business since the 1930's, when Leo Fenster Agency was formed giving equal ownership rights to Leo, Robert & Marc Fenster.

The trio of grandfather, father & son had big plans for the future of the agency when Leo Fenster suddenly passed away.

Just as Leo had to carry on after his father passed away, Robert & Marc had to pick up the pieces and maintain business as usual. Leo wouldn't have wanted it any other way.

Today, Leo Fenster Agency along with it's sister company Fenster & Company Real Estate continue to serve the community as friendly and family-oriented as ever. We offer our clients only the best service and attention that you would expect from over a half century of experience.

The future of Leo Fenster Agency, just as the past, revolves around our extended family - our clients. We are constantly looking for new products from quality companies to accommodate our clients' ever changing needs. We are and always will be your family in the business!